Key takeaways

  • Transfers between related people (parents, children, siblings, spouses, controlled corporations) are “non-arm’s length” under s.251.
  • If you sell to a related person below fair market value (FMV), you are taxed as if you received FMV — but the buyer’s cost is only what they paid.
  • That mismatch creates double taxation: in our example, a $1 sale costs the family about $120,000 more than an outright gift.
  • A gift, a sale at FMV with a promissory note, or a staged plan using the capital gains reserve are usually far better options.

01 — A REAL STORYThe $1 sale that almost happened

★From our client files

A client came to us with what seemed like a clever way to pass on a rental property: sell it to the children for $1. The reasoning was simple — “If I sell for a dollar, I don’t make a gain, so I won’t owe tax.”

The reality was very different. The CRA would ignore the $1 price and tax the parent as though the property sold at fair market value, creating a tax bill of nearly $100,000 on “phantom” proceeds never received. Worse, the children would inherit a cost base of only $1 and pay tax again on almost the entire value when they eventually sold. By planning the transfer properly instead, the family avoided paying tax twice.

This is exactly the situation section 69 of the Income Tax Act was written to address.

02 — THE RULESection 69: the rule you can’t ignore

Subsection 69(1) governs transfers between parties who are not dealing at arm’s length when the price does not match fair market value. It works in three directions:

a
Buying above FMV

The buyer’s cost is deemed to be only FMV.

s.69(1)(a)
b
Selling below FMV (or gifting)

The seller’s proceeds are deemed to be FMV.

s.69(1)(b)
c
Receiving a gift or inheritance

The recipient’s cost is deemed to be FMV.

s.69(1)(c)

Notice what is missing: there is no rule that bumps up the buyer’s cost when they pay less than FMV. That one-sided gap is what makes a $1 sale so expensive. The provisions prevent families from:

  • Transferring property for $1 to sidestep capital gains;
  • Inflating costs to create artificial losses; and
  • Passing business value to the next generation without the growth ever being taxed.
iIn plain English

Between family members, the CRA taxes the economic reality, not the price written in the contract.

03 — DEFINITIONSWhat does “non-arm’s length” mean?

Section 69 only applies when the parties are not dealing at arm’s length. There are two routes into that category:

1. Related persons (automatic)

Under s.251, related persons are deemed not to deal at arm’s length — including parents and children (and grandchildren), siblings, spouses and common-law partners, in-laws, and corporations controlled by any of them.

2. Unrelated, but not independent (factual)

Even unrelated parties can be non-arm’s length if the deal doesn’t reflect independent bargaining. Courts consider:

  • Common mind — one mind directing both sides?
  • Acting in concert — no separate interests?
  • De facto control — does one party dominate?

In practice, almost every family transfer falls squarely into the non-arm’s-length category.

04 — THE PROBLEMWhy selling below fair market value backfires

Problem 1 Phantom income

The parent is deemed to sell at FMV but receives only $1. The tax bill is real; the cash to pay it isn’t.

Problem 2 The mismatch

The parent is taxed on the gain up to FMV, but the child’s adjusted cost base (ACB) is just $1 — so the same growth is taxed again when the child sells.

✓Why a gift is better

A gift still triggers FMV proceeds for the parent under s.69(1)(b), but the child’s ACB is stepped up to FMV under s.69(1)(c). The parent pays the same tax — but the child is only taxed on growth after the transfer. A $1 sale is the worst of both worlds.

05 — WORKED EXAMPLEA $1 house sale vs. a gift

A parent owns a rental property bought for $200,000, now worth $500,000. The child later sells it for $600,000. We assume a 50% capital gains inclusion rate and a combined marginal tax rate of roughly 48% for both parent and child.

Item$1 saleGift
Parent’s deemed proceeds (FMV)$500,000$500,000
Parent’s ACB$200,000$200,000
Parent’s capital gain → taxable (50%)$300,000 → $150,000$300,000 → $150,000
Parent’s tax (≈48%)$72,000$72,000
Child’s ACB$1$500,000
Child’s gain on later $600,000 sale → taxable$599,999 → ≈$300,000$100,000 → $50,000
Child’s tax (≈48%)$144,000$24,000
Total family tax≈ $216,000≈ $96,000
Plus any recapture of capital cost allowance (CCA) previously claimed on the rental, which is taxed to the parent in both scenarios under s.13(1). Illustrative figures; actual rates depend on income and province.
Total family tax: $1 sale vs. gift
Same property, same parent tax — the difference is entirely the child’s second layer of tax
Parent’s taxChild’s tax on later sale
$1 sale $72,000$144,000 ≈ $216,000 Gift $72,000$24,000 ≈ $96,000
The $1 sale costs the family roughly $120,000 more than simply gifting the same property.

06 — ALTERNATIVESBetter ways to transfer property to your children

Outright gift

Parent pays tax on the accrued gain; child receives a full FMV cost base. No double tax.

Sale at FMV with a note

Sell at full value, take a promissory note, and spread the gain using the capital gains reserve (generally up to 5 years).

Staged or corporate planning

For businesses, estate freezes, family trusts and the intergenerational transfer rules may allow growth to shift with less tax today.

!Other issues to check before transferring
  • Principal residence: if the property was your home, the principal residence exemption may shelter some or all of your gain.
  • Attribution rules: gifting income-producing property to a minor child can attribute rental or investment income back to you until they turn 18.
  • Recapture and land transfer tax: CCA recapture on rentals and provincial land transfer tax can add to the cost.

07 — REFERENCESCRA and Income Tax Act references

ITA
s.69(1)(a), (b), (c) — non-arm’s length transfers: deemed proceeds and deemed cost rules.
ITA
s.251 — arm’s length and related persons.
ITA
s.13(1) — recapture of depreciation on rental property.
ITA
s.40(1)(a)(iii) — capital gains reserve on deferred proceeds.
CRA
Income Tax Folio S1-F5-C1, Related persons and dealing at arm’s length