Key takeaways

  • A personal service business (PSB) exists when an incorporated worker would reasonably be considered an employee of the client but for the corporation.
  • PSB income is taxed at about 44.5% in Ontario (33% federal) — versus about 12.2% with the small business deduction.
  • Deductions are limited mainly to salary and benefits paid to the worker — normal business expenses are denied.
  • Courts first ask what the parties intended, then test it against control, tools, and chance of profit or risk of loss.

01 — WHY IT MATTERSAre you self-employed or an employee?

This question has far-reaching tax and legal consequences. It determines how you’re taxed, what you can deduct, who withholds CPP and EI, and what protections you have.

★A common scenario

Alex, a skilled IT consultant, had been an employee of a software company for years. To “save costs,” the company suggested he leave and bill them as an independent contractor. Alex incorporated, expecting tax savings. Months later, a letter arrived from the CRA suggesting his corporation might be a personal service business — a designation with significant tax consequences.

02 — THE TESTEmployee or independent contractor: how the CRA decides

There is no single statutory definition. Courts apply a two-step approach developed in case law (Connor Homes, 2013 FCA), built on the Supreme Court’s central question in Sagaz (2001): is the worker in business on their own account?

1
What did the parties intend?

Look at the contract and conduct: did both sides intend an employment or a contractor relationship?

→
2
Does reality match?

Test that intention against the objective factors below. Intention can’t override the facts.

Control

Who decides what work is done, how and when? Less telling for skilled professionals who need little direction.

Tools & equipment

Who supplies — and pays to maintain — the tools? Less telling for knowledge workers whose main tool is expertise.

Profit & loss

Can the worker profit from efficiency, or lose money (bad debts, unrecovered costs, fixed-price projects)?

iWhat about the “integration” test?

Older cases asked whether the worker was integrated into the payer’s business, or economically dependent on it. Recent Tax Court decisions (including Insurance Institute of Ontario, 2020 TCC 69) treat it as unhelpful because it skews toward finding employment. Factors like having multiple clients or receiving employee-style benefits are still considered as part of the overall picture.

03 — DEFINITIONWhat is a personal service business?

A PSB is often called an “incorporated employee.” Under ITA 125(7), a corporation carries on a PSB when:

1
The worker owns 10%+

The individual performing the services (or a related person) is a specified shareholder — generally owning 10% or more of any class of shares.

2
But for the corporation…

…the individual would reasonably be regarded as an employee of the client.

Exception 1

The corporation employs more than five full-time employees throughout the year.

Exception 2

The services are provided to an associated corporation.

04 — THE COSTImplications of PSB classification

Combined federal + Ontario corporate tax rate, 2026
On the same dollar of corporate income
Small business rateGeneral ratePSB income ≈ 12.2% 26.5% 44.5%
PSB income loses the small business deduction and the general rate reduction, and pays an extra 5% federal tax.
Normal CCPCFederal rate
Base rate38%
Federal abatement(10%)
Small business deduction(19%)
Federal rate9%
PSBFederal rate
Base rate38%
Federal abatement(10%)
PSB surtax+5%
Federal rate33%

Restricted expense deductions — ITA 18(1)(p)

A PSB can deduct essentially only:

  • Salary, wages and benefits paid to the individual who performs the services; and
  • Expenses that would have been deductible to an employee (e.g., certain sales or travel costs under section 8), plus some legal costs of collecting fees.

“Normal” business expenses — office costs, advertising, most travel, accounting — are not deductible, increasing taxable income further.

✓Planning tip

If PSB risk can’t be eliminated, paying out the corporation’s income as salary to the worker (which is deductible) can prevent most income from being taxed at the 44.5% corporate rate.

05 — COMPARISONEmployee vs. independent contractor

AspectEmployeeIndependent contractor
Income typeEmployment incomeBusiness income
TimingTaxed when received (cash basis)Taxed when earned (accrual basis)
Deductible expensesLimited (section 8)Any reasonable expense to earn income
Source deductionsEmployer withholds tax, CPP and EIPays own tax and both halves of CPP; EI optional (special benefits only)
Economic securityEmployment standards, notice/severance, benefitsNo statutory severance; takes commercial risk
Poor workCan be disciplined or dismissedCan be sued for breach of contract
ToolsUsually provided by the employerUsually supplied by the contractor
Profit / lossNo risk of lossOpportunity for profit and risk of loss

06 — FAQFrequently asked questions

How does the CRA decide whether my corporation is a PSB?

It asks whether you would reasonably be considered the client’s employee if the corporation didn’t exist — looking at intention, control, tools, financial risk, and whether you serve multiple clients. Contracts help, but only if the actual working relationship matches them.

Can I avoid PSB classification?

The surest ways are the statutory exceptions — more than five full-time employees, or services to an associated corporation. Otherwise, the relationship must genuinely look like a business: multiple clients, your own tools and premises, control over how work is done, and real financial risk.

Does the CRA look back at prior years?

Yes. PSB reassessments often cover several years at once, with interest — making the cost of getting it wrong much higher than a single year’s tax difference.

07 — REFERENCESLegislation and case law

ITA
s.125(7) — definition of personal service business and the exceptions · s.123.5 — additional 5% tax · s.18(1)(p) — deduction limits.
CRA
Guide RC4110, Employee or Self-Employed? — the CRA’s approach to worker status.
CASE
671122 Ontario Ltd. v. Sagaz Industries Canada Inc., 2001 SCC 59 — the central question: is the worker in business on their own account?
CASE
Wiebe Door Services Ltd. v. M.N.R., [1986] 3 FC 553 (FCA) — the combined factors of control, tools, profit and risk of loss.
CASE
Royal Winnipeg Ballet v. M.N.R., 2006 FCA 87 — the parties’ common intention matters where the facts are consistent with it.
CASE
1392644 Ontario Inc. (Connor Homes) v. M.N.R., 2013 FCA 85 — the two-step test: intention, then objective reality.
CASE
Insurance Institute of Ontario v. M.N.R., 2020 TCC 69 — applies the two-step test; common intention prevailed; integration test disfavoured.
CASE
Montreal v. Montreal Locomotive Works Ltd., [1947] 1 DLR 161 (PC) — origin of the “fourfold” test.