Key takeaways
- Changing a property between personal use and rental use triggers a deemed disposition at fair market value under s.45(1) — tax with no cash.
- A 45(2) election (home → rental) or 45(3) election (rental → home) cancels that deemed sale.
- With 45(2), you can keep designating the property as your principal residence for up to 4 extra years while it’s rented — longer if you moved for work.
- No capital cost allowance can be claimed, and you must keep strong records of value and use.
In this article
01 — A REAL STORYTurning knowledge into real savings
At Elkhanagry Accounting we often say that tax planning isn’t just about filing forms — it’s about finding the opportunities built into the Income Tax Act.
A client bought a Toronto condo, lived in it for a year, then moved back in with his parents and rented the condo out rather than leave it empty. Four years later he sold it with a gain of roughly $200,000. Normally, those four rental years would not qualify for the principal residence exemption (PRE). Because we filed a section 45(2) election, he could treat the condo as his principal residence for those years — saving him tens of thousands of dollars in tax.
02 — THE DEFAULT RULEWhat is a change of use?
A change of use happens when you convert a property from personal use (such as your principal residence) to income-producing use (such as a rental), or the reverse.
🏠 → 🔑 Personal to rental
You’re deemed to sell at FMV and reacquire at the same value. If the home rose in value, a capital gain arises (often sheltered by the PRE for the years you lived there).
🔑 → 🏠 Rental to personal
You’re deemed to sell at FMV, crystallizing the taxable gain from the rental years — even though nothing was sold.
This rule under s.45(1) stops people from deferring gains indefinitely by switching how a property is used. But it can produce tax bills with no cash to pay them. That’s where subsections 45(2) and 45(3) come in.
03 — THE ELECTIONSThe power of section 45(2) and 45(3)
45(2) Moving out
When: you move out of your home and start renting it.
Effect: you’re deemed not to have changed its use. No deemed sale, and you can keep designating it as your principal residence for up to four rental years.
45(3) Moving back in
When: a property that was always a rental becomes your home.
Effect: the deemed sale is cancelled, and up to four earlier rental years can be designated as principal residence years.
1. Deferral
No tax on conversion. You control when gains are recognized — on the actual sale.
2. A longer PRE
Up to four extra PRE years, often sheltering six-figure gains.
3. Flexibility
Moving for work, living with family, or downsizing — without being penalized.
04 — FINE PRINTConditions, limits and pitfalls
| Condition | What you need to know |
|---|---|
| Filing deadline | 45(2): file a signed letter with your return for the year the use changed (by its filing due date). 45(3): file by the due date of your return for the year you actually sell — or earlier if the CRA requests it. |
| Late elections | The CRA can accept late elections. A late-filing penalty applies under s.220(3.5): $100 per complete month late, up to $8,000. (Filed 12 months late → $1,200.) |
| Four-year limit | A 45(2) property can be designated for up to 4 rental years. You must be resident in Canada for those years. |
| Moved for work? | Under s.54.1, the four-year limit can be extended indefinitely if you or your spouse relocated at least 40 km for employment and you move back while still with that employer (or by the end of the year after leaving). |
| One residence per family | Only one property per family unit can be designated for any given year. |
| No CCA | If any capital cost allowance is claimed on the property (by you, your spouse, or a trust for your benefit), a 45(2) election is rescinded. 45(3) isn’t available if CCA was claimed after 1984. |
| Partial changes | Since March 19, 2019, both elections are available for partial changes in use — e.g., renting out a basement unit. |
| Records | Keep evidence of FMV at conversion (an appraisal is ideal), leases, and proof of where you lived. |
You still report rental income and can deduct ordinary expenses (interest, property tax, repairs) — just not CCA. In most cases, the PRE protection is worth far more than the CCA you give up.
05 — CASE STUDYJoe Shmoe saves $50,000 with a 45(2) election
| 2018 gain ($300k − $290k), sheltered by PRE | $0 tax |
| New cost base | $300,000 |
| 2023 gain ($500k − $300k) | $200,000 |
| Taxable capital gain (50%) | $100,000 |
| Tax at 50% | $50,000 |
| Total gain ($500k − $290k) | $210,000 |
| Years designated (2018 + 4 rental years) | 5 |
| Exempt portion: (1 + 5) ÷ 6 years owned | 100% |
| Taxable capital gain | $0 |
| Tax | $0 |
Assumes no other property was designated by Joe’s family unit for 2018–2022 and Joe remained a Canadian resident throughout. Result: $50,000 of tax avoided by filing one election.


